Category: Florida BAR article
-
A Primer on Counties and Municipalities Part 1
Florida’s counties are important political divisions that are created by the state legislature. There are 67 counties in Florida, and they can be either charter counties, which have their own local government rules, or noncharter counties. Charter counties must have their charter approved by the voters in a special election. This means that the people…
-
Economic Redevelopment of Small-city Downtowns: Options and Considerations for the Practitioner Part 2
The Main Street Approach focuses on four things to help downtown areas: organization, promotion and marketing, design, and economic restructuring. All these things work together to make downtown better. For organization, everyone in the downtown area needs to work together to make a plan for the future. This includes the chamber of commerce, merchants, and…
-
Economic Redevelopment of Small-city Downtowns: Options and Considerations for the Practitioner
Downtowns in small cities have faced economic problems since the 1950s, with businesses moving to the suburbs or closing down due to the popularity of shopping centers and discount superstores. However, in the past 20 years, there has been a revival in small-city downtowns, with more people and businesses choosing to live and work there.…
-
Implementing School Concurrency: The Challenges of Adopting a United Vision
If a developer wants to build houses, they have to show that there will be enough space in the schools for the kids who will live in those houses. This rule only applies to houses, not to stores or businesses. That’s because stores and businesses don’t directly bring kids to the schools. The law requires…
-
Redefining Quasi-judicial: The Diminishing Role of Quasi-judicial Determinations in Local Government Personnel Actions
A corrections officer in Miami-Dade County was disciplined for having a relationship with a former inmate. She appealed her punishment through the county’s process, but then filed a lawsuit in a different court. The appeals court said she couldn’t do that because she already used the county’s process. They said she had to appeal within…
-
Laws from on High: Religious Displays on Public Property
The Ten Commandments monument was removed from a building in Alabama, causing a big argument. People are split on whether it’s okay to have religious stuff in public places. Roy Moore, the chief judge of the Alabama Supreme Court, put the monument there and now people don’t agree on whether he did the right thing…
-
Striking Affirmative Defenses in Government Litigation
In government cases, affirmative defenses are reasons why the government shouldn’t be able to take action against someone. For example, if a government employee gives wrong information to a person’s lawyer, that might not be enough to help the person in a legal case. It can be hard to use certain affirmative defenses in government…
-
Senate Bill 360: Growth Management Reform Arrives and It Is All About Infrastructure
The legislature passed a bill (S.B. 360) that gives some extra money for infrastructure, but it’s not enough to cover all the needs. The bill was being changed and negotiated up until the last minute, so no one really knows what’s in it. It’s likely that there will be another bill in 2006 to fix…
-
Eenie, Meenie, Miney, Mo . . . Who’s To Regulate This Tow?
Local governments are like the designated “It” in a game of tag, trying to figure out if they can make their own rules for towing companies. Some court cases have given them some authority, but it’s still a bit confusing. We’ll look at what rules local governments can make for towing services. Towing services in…
-
The High Cost of Arrestee Medical Treatment: The Effects of F.S. §901.35 on Local Government Coffers
Florida’s local governments are struggling with the rising cost of medical insurance. There is a state law that says the person who gets hurt during an arrest is responsible for paying their own medical expenses. But in reality, the hospitals first try to get the money from the person’s insurance, then from the person, and…
-
Advising the Client Regarding Protection of Property Rights: Harris Act and Inverse Condemnation Claims
This article talks about the challenges that real estate practitioners face when advising clients on protecting their property rights. It covers two aspects of property rights: compensation for a government taking property, and rights under Florida’s Harris Act. These are complex issues and the law is still evolving, so itâs important to consult with a…
-
Shade Meetings: Overview, Pitfalls, and Recommended Changes
The attorney-client exemption to the Sunshine Law allows government entities to meet in private with their attorneys to discuss legal matters. To do this, they must follow certain procedures. Courts have interpreted this exemption in different ways. The law should be changed to make it more helpful for government entities. In Florida, it’s the law…
-
Regulating Public Access Programming Without Violating First Amendment Rights
Congress passed a law called 47 U.S.C. §531 to give local governments the power to require cable companies to set aside channels for public, educational, or government use. These channels are called PEG channels. The public access channel is part of the PEG and is where citizens can make their own TV shows. The government…
-
Skating on Thin Concrete: The Florida Legislature’s Response to Skateboarders and Skaters
Skateboarders and in-line skaters are causing problems for public officials. The Florida Legislature has made a law to encourage the government to provide places for skating, but it’s still a challenge for officials to figure out their liability. The government is worried about being sued if people get hurt while skateboarding, inline skating, or biking.…
-
Should the Narrowing Scope of Second-tier Certiorari Mandate Findings of Fact in Local Government Quasi-judicial Decisions?
The Florida Supreme Court is looking at the rules for how lower courts review decisions made by local governments. Right now, they can only check if the law was followed, not if the decision was right. The Supreme Court may change the rules to make local governments write down their reasons for decisions. This would…
-
An Examination of the Background, Issues, and Ramifications Surrounding the Stadium Litigation in Tampa
The people of Hillsborough County voted to use public money to build a new sports stadium in Tampa. A former mayor filed a complaint saying it was unconstitutional to use public funds for this. The government then filed a complaint to validate the bonds for the stadium’s construction. Both complaints were heard in court, and…
-
State v. Lopez: Florida’s New âOn-going Emergency Rule
The Florida Supreme Court recently made a new rule for determining if an excited utterance is testimonial in the case of State v. Lopez. This article reviews what an excited utterance is, the Supreme Court case Crawford v. Washington, and the new rule from the Florida Supreme Court. It argues that the new rule is…
-
Florida Public Records Law: The Battle Over Attorneys’ Fees
The public records law in Florida gives people the right to access government records. But there are a lot of rules and exceptions that make it complicated. Recently, there have been a lot of lawsuits about this, and it’s been hard for government agencies to follow the law. Some people have been taking advantage of…
-
Up Allen’s Creek Without a Paddle: Can Cities Leverage Utility Service for Annexation?
The Florida Supreme Court decided that cities can make property owners in unincorporated areas join the city in order to get access to city utilities. This helps spread the costs of utilities to more people and prevents county residents from enjoying city benefits without paying city taxes. This is a controversial issue that continues to…
-
Another Fine Mess: Are Non-ad Valorem Special Assessments for Local Government Nuisance Abatement Charges Legally Defensible?
Cities in Florida are dealing with a problem of neglected and abandoned properties that violate city codes and create health and safety issues. These properties have racked up huge fines, but the city has a hard time collecting the money. To solve this problem, some cities are considering adding the costs of cleaning up these…
-
Decision by Judge or Jury? Alternatives to Traditional Code Enforcement Boards
Florida cities and counties have the power to enforce their local codes through code enforcement boards. These boards are made up of community volunteers who have the authority to make final decisions on violations and fines. The only way to challenge their decisions is to appeal to the local circuit court. There are benefits to…
-
The Bert J. Harris, Jr., Private Property Rights Protection Act: An Overview, Recent Developments, and What the Future May Hold
Florida has a law called the Bert J. Harris, Jr., Private Property Rights Protection Act that helps landowners when government actions affect their property. It has been amended to make it easier for landowners to file claims, but courts have been cautious in granting relief. There is still confusion about what is protected under the…
-
Me, Myself, and I: Does Florida’s Sunshine Law Apply to Communications of a Lone Member of a Board or Commission?
As a city council member in Florida, you have to be careful about how you conduct your work outside of public meetings. The Sunshine Law requires that all meetings where official acts are to be taken must be open to the public and provide reasonable notice. This means that any discussions or actions that could…
-
Rodriguez v. Miami-Dade County:The Florida Supreme Court Clarifies Certiorari Review in Sovereign Immunity Cases
In the past, courts sometimes allowed immediate review of orders denying a government’s motion to dismiss a case based on sovereign immunity. But a recent ruling by the Florida Supreme Court has ended this practice. The court said that certiorari review should only be allowed in rare cases where there is a serious legal mistake…